Le Foglie Morte: Power Poll! [And Challenge]
I take a certain pride in writing detailed previews of major races, usually before CyclingNews gets theirs going, for the simple reason that races like Saturday's Giro di Lombardia deserve a full week of rumination befitting the glorious history, magnificent course, and the likelihood of some memorable action about to take place. Sadly, I also pride myself on retaining and otherwise performing in my day job, which has become increasingly demanding over the last several weeks, including what can only be called a big slug of work this week. Taken together with a distracting election, the Red Sox' refusal to go quietly into that good night, a similar phenomenon in my wife's work schedule, and my having snack duty at DS Littler Bear's preschool co-op, and you've got... a really lame week for blogging.
So since the previews are all out there, and Pez has ridden and photographed every meter of the course, I think there's little for me to add besides some (cough) "insight" into who might win. As we like to say here at One Podium Cafe Plaza, when all else fails... Power Poll! w/o ado...
1. Damiano Cunego, Lampre
Was it only yesterday that I introduced my latest dissertation, on how classics riders are more versatile than you (OK, I) might think? Fine, but there are a handful of matches made in heaven in Cycling, and this is one of them. If the creator sculpted Tom Boonen for the Tour of Flanders, then so too did s/he concoct Damiano Cunego for Lombardia. The longish (for a classic) climbs of Lombardia are no problem for this former Alpe d'Huez runner-up, and among the climbers-who-sprint class, only Valverde is as fast as Cunego on a flat finish. So as for tomorrow: where do you drop him? And in a limited field sprint, who's gonna beat him? Valverde could, but he's home. So is Cunego.
2. Sammy Sanchez, Euskaltel
If there is a single feature of this course that's not tailor-made for Cunego, it's the winding, twisting descents of the Civiglio and San Fermo della Battaglia, occupying most of the last 15km. Not that he can't do it, as Cunego's two Lombardia triumphs attest, but he's not the master of the downhill. That's Sam-(in)San(e)'s domain. Sure, the strongest guy will probably find a way to win tomorrow, but if you had to think of a strategy that could prevail against Cunego, and a guy to pull it off, this is it. Sammy was third last year for this reason. This time, if he can get to the top of the Civiglio with the front of the peloton, rather than chasing the Kid, he's got a chance.
3. Stefano Garzelli, Acqua e Sapone
After the top two slots, the major theme of this year's race is the veritable who's who list of climbing-sprinty-classicians ... who aren't coming. Danilo DiLuca's LPR team got snubbed. Valverde begged off. Rebellin's Gerolsteiner team pulled the plug after the Chimney Sweep fessed up. Ricco is off breaking rocks someplace. And Basso's suspension runs conveniently into the middle of next week.
I'm not crazy about Garzelli here, but when he's on top of his game he's pretty much the same guy as Cunego. In the last month he won the GP Wallonie, finished third in the Coppa Sabatini, was 10th at Lazio and 14th at Emilia. I'm not sure what exactly that says about his form, but in the latter case he finished next to Cunego, and nobody's stressing over Cunego's form. He's also almost certainly carrying around the hurt of his non-selection for the worlds team in his hometown of Varese... nobody comes in with a bigger chip on his shoulder.
4. Cadel Evans, Silence! Lotto
Hm, except maybe this guy. Evans has different reasons for wanting redemption/revenge, and all his even-handed post-race debriefing surely masks some disappointed ambition. He's the biggest name in the race, all things considered. But he can't really sprint, and it's a little hard to imagine him dropping all the Italians before the finale.
5. Joaquim Rodriguez, Caisse d'Epargne
With Valverde home, J-Rod takes the reigns of Spain's power-squad. I don't really think he'll win, but Jered's point in the Pez preview is well taken: Rodriguez is always in the mix, and can finish off a sprint, despite the fact that he's usually tasked with shepherding Valverde home instead. He was also the only Spaniard to make the final gruppetto (sucking on Ballan's dust) at Varese, so his form is presumably about right. Honestly, Evans outranks him here in name only.
6. Alexandr Kolobnev, CSC
Mr. Can I Buy a Vowel always saves his best for last. Last autumn he finished second in the worlds, won the inaugural Monte Paschi Eroica, ran 9th at Emilia and finally 11th in Lombardia. This year he's arguably even better conditioned for Lombardia: he finished third at Emilia to two riders who aren't here, and took 5th in the Coppa Sabatini. He also sports an all-star support lineup of Gustov, McCartney, Larsson, Kroon and Sorensen, any one of whom could be considered longshots to do something as well. [Andy Schleck is not on the startlist, BTW.] I still wouldn't bet on him in a flat sprint against Cunego or Rodriguez, but at the end of a hard race, if he's the strongest guy left, I wouldn't dismiss the possibility.
Others, in no particular order:
Domenico Pozzovivo... but I doubt anyone wants a reprise of the CSF shocker. Vincenzo Nibali... hasn't been especially good lately. Liquigas are really sitting this one out, aren't they? Robert Gesink... surprise me on the descent, and he'll be in the finale. Chris Horner... would be the story of the year. Ah well. Mick Rogers... redemption? He's usually in form for the worlds, though that hasn't helped him much at Lombardia. Still, 11th last week at GP Beghelli. The Flying Masciarellis... when's the last time three brothers took the start together at a monument, in the same uniform? And, once more for good measure, Angel Gomez Gomez Gomez... here's wishing you a safe ride.
And a challenge:
Who ya got? Send in your top three by midnight tonight. Whoever has the best podium (scored on a 7-5-3 scale, with 1 point for getting the right name on the wrong podium step) gets a prize from the Schwag Bag.
71 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
What's up with Gerdemann?
Is he still hurt? I know he had neck problems after the D-Tour. He is not on the start list for Columbia, which is too bad. This is a race he can win one day.
Anywho, my podium picks are Kolobnev, Sanchez, and Cunego. In that order.
A Rebellin Without A Ride
I would have taken Davide Rebellin, for the win this year, but in any case, let’s go with…
1. Garzelli
2. Cunego
3. Sanchez
Enjoy the race !!
Why did they ever disconnect the toll free Barfko Swill Hotline ??? WHY !!!???
by FrankEffinZappa on Oct 17, 2008 2:40 PM EDT reply actions
Kolobnev is a diesel
If the finish is flat and he gets a gap, it’s game over. But, he can sprint to. If I’m Cunego or Sanchez, I’m not bringing him with me. He won Eroica, so we know he has the power. He doesn’t have Cunego’s sprint, but he more than makes up for it in raw power. Not to mention Kroon. I think Cunego and Sanchez better be careful. Good write-up by the way.
If I just had one more gear, I...
Thanks!
So who ya got for #s 2 and 3?
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 17, 2008 3:21 PM EDT up reply actions
That's a tough one
I actually think that Cunego is probably going to win, but I think Kolobnev will be 2nd and Sam San will be 3rd. I think the elite group will be something like:
Cunego
Evans
Sam San
Garzelli
Pfannberger ( I like this guy)
Horner (fo sho)
Mick Rogers
Kolobnev
Kroon ( I like this guy too)
Gesink (I like this guy too)
Axelsson (like Jens said below. He’s on a great season)
However it turns out, I couldn’t be disappointed at all. These guys are all studs.
If I just had one more gear, I...
Now that
is a prediction. The whole top 11.
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 17, 2008 9:13 PM EDT up reply actions
it is flat for a short distance.
They climb the Civiglio, then it’s a crazy ass descent, then about 2 km or so of flat to the line. Usually a group of three or so make it to the line, though Bettini won it solo from the Civiglio a year or so back.
I'm going to go with what my heart tells me
1. Horner
2. Axelsson
3. CA Sörensen
How can one not like a guy like Horner? He deserves one big win to crown his career
Carlos Sastre - Tour de France winner - Born From Jets
OK, I'm going with who is left on my VDS
Maxime Monfort
Yaroslav Popovych
Erki Putsep
Plus, I make a friendly wager that Pavel Brutt goes in an early breakaway.
"The world is a mess and I just need to rule it." Dr. Horrible
Bet
I’d take you up on the Brutt challenge, except that early breakaway will be at about 2am Pacific.
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 17, 2008 4:18 PM EDT up reply actions
Yep
I’m on 4 hrs sleep. There is no more vital matter in my life right now.
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 17, 2008 5:04 PM EDT up reply actions
heh
in my dreams. No, wait…
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 17, 2008 6:26 PM EDT up reply actions
I'll go with a combination of what I want to see and what just MIGHT happen...
Sammy
J-Rod
Cunego
I will be at work tomorrow. Sympathy please. I might be able to watch a little….
Yell fro Cadel
1. Evans
2. Sanchez
3. Cunego

by cyclingchallenge on Oct 17, 2008 4:39 PM EDT reply actions
As an aside
A very fitting title / photo
At least where I am, on certain quiet roads/hills the leaves are currently
a real hazard / challenge
by cyclingchallenge on Oct 17, 2008 4:45 PM EDT reply actions
I'll Take
1. Damiano Cunego (ITA)
2. Cadel Evans (AUS)
3. Samuel Sanchez Gonzalez (ESP)
Looking at the start list I noticed that Michele Scarponi is listed. I didn’t realize he was back racing. It will be interesting to see how he does as I would think this would be a race that suits his talents (or a race he would do well in prior to his ban).
Yes
He came back during August or somewhere around that time. He’s been riding the Italian one day races, mostly as a support rider for eh, the guy who crashed and ended his season early, rode well at worlds last year, crappo, I can’t think of his name. Bleh. Anywho, Scarponi, back racing.
sam insane
I’ll take
1. SamSan
2. Rodriguez
3. Kolobnev
lol
I wanted to write something about Lombardia, cuz it’s one of my fave races of the whole year. But then I read that first Pez preview and was far too humbled to make the attempt. That was far far better than anything I could hope to come up with. LOL, so let’s just out-source Lombardia to Pez this year :-)
Eh, podium.
Damiano Cunego Vai!
Alexandre Kolobnev
Gibo Simoni
lol
it was either that or Garze but i went gibo, cuz i so heart it when gibo and cunego are in a break together…
What has Gibo done since il Giro?
_________gibogibo____________gibogibog
______gibogibogibogi_______gibogibogibogibo
____gibogibogibogibogib___gibogibogibogibogib
___gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibo_______gibo
__gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibo_________gibo
_gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibo_______gibo
_gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibo______g
gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibo__gib
gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogib_g
gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibog
gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibog
gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogib
_gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibog
____gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogi
______gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibogibog
_________gibogibogibogibogibogibogibogib
____________gibogibogibogibogibogibog
______________gibogibogibogibogibo
_________________gibogibogibog
___________________gibogibog
_____________________gibogi
______________________gibo
_______________________gi
I see
a huge hole in the right ventricle. Seriously, he should have that looked at.
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 17, 2008 6:28 PM EDT up reply actions
gone mountain biking
i think he placed at a one day race over the last month or so. but really, i have no idea. he did good at this race a few times before, so i said, why not. i like that guy.
No why do you includ Pfannenberger..
Though I would be the only one :P
But my pick..
1 Pfannenberger
2 Kolobnev
3 Ballan
Some say the best things in life, are one the inside.
Hey
I almost put him in the power poll.
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 17, 2008 7:23 PM EDT up reply actions
My picks
1) Garzelli
2) Horner
3) Cunego
In terms of the GarMen, I’d look at Dan Martin and maybe (ehh, probably not) Tommy D to do the best here. Huub Duyn’s also more of a classics type and a Rabo Espoirs steal like Maaskant, so he’s another young guy to look for. Dan Martin would be my pick to place highest from the GarMen, though.
Benissimo! on the Power Poll, Chris.
My picks:
Sammy
Kolobnev
Cunego
Here’s hoping the Garmen & Gerdemann are protagonists, too!
All italian podium...
1. Cunego
2. Garzelli
3. Nocentini
I’ve been away for the last 4 days and am very upset to hear that Tin-Tin Rebellin isn’t competing. I hate Bernhard Kohl and the VDS points I got from him.
So
you’re giving them back? Jens would like to know.
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 17, 2008 9:13 PM EDT up reply actions
If everyone gives back Ricco points, I'll give back Kohl points.
Dumb SOB, Kohl that is.
by brunopitton on Oct 17, 2008 10:13 PM EDT up reply actions
Don't forget Sella points:(
Well, at least those guys were caught and aren’t riding Lombardia. No solace for Tin-Tin, though.
VDS-wise, I’ve got Samsan, Monfort, and Kroon. Unless that’s the podium, there’s no threat to the technicolor jersey from Fromagerie Duval.
To be clear
I took away Ricco’s points in the Tour. But that was in real time. I didn’t take away his Giro points.
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 18, 2008 12:57 AM EDT up reply actions
FYI Even taking away all points of dopers caught during the season
will NOT (with 99% certainty) change the winner of this years VDS which I think is excellent.
Carlos Sastre - Tour de France winner - Born From Jets
Sopwith Camels need to sweep this race or never race again.
J Rod nips Kolobnev at the line and Cunego is upset with third place.
I googled it, it must be true.
My picks from the dartboard
1) Kolobnev
2) Freire
3) Cunego
One thing I always look forward to (and with a bit of sadness)
is the Lombardia story from Chris. I link this story to his earlier one on the Classics in that both bring me an immense amount of joy to read.
I am a commenter, a leech on others work. Chris is a real writer, whose love of the Classics echoes my own but whose ability to express it in a beautiful manner far exceeds my own. Vai Damiano!
Oh, and if I can ask but one favor from everyone tomorrow and Sunday, please no spoilers on the winner in any postings. I can’t watch the race until late afternoon, two days hence. Grazie.
"I have come here to chew bubblegum and kick ass... and I'm all out of bubblegum."
Funny Lynny :-)
Hey, that’s kind of like Happy Puppy.
"I have come here to chew bubblegum and kick ass... and I'm all out of bubblegum."
such a mensch
So where are your picks?
"If writing too much about the Classics is wrong, I don't want to be right."
by Chris Fontecchio on Oct 18, 2008 1:02 AM EDT up reply actions
Oh yes, that
1. Garzelli
2. Cunego
3. Lloyd
I’m feeling frisky, plus it’s 36F right now and I have to race in 4 hours.
Fuuuuuuuuuuuuck!
"I have come here to chew bubblegum and kick ass... and I'm all out of bubblegum."
If it were two months later, yes :-)
I was at a race on the shore a few years ago in early October when it started snowing before and during my race (the really wet, heavy stuff). 10 miles inland it was bone dry. Really freaky.
"I have come here to chew bubblegum and kick ass... and I'm all out of bubblegum."
It's a classic..
Their probably good guys in the front..
Some say the best things in life, are one the inside.
Lloyd looked strong in the final k video of Emilia, that would be a fun surprise-winner.
Carlos Sastre - Tour de France winner - Born From Jets
I thought Matt Lloyd was a good pick too
but I suspect that he will hang around too long seeing if Cadel has the legs.
I’ll go for:
Ballan
Kolobnev
Garzelli

by 














![This is funny on so many levels. [Html should open bigger]](http://cdn3.sbnation.com/fan_shot_images/239959/flagged_small.jpg)


