Priorities, Part Two: Three Regions
Priorities, Part One- Grand Tours here.
Season VDS totals of the teams here.
WARNING!!! Numbers- lots of 'em!- follow!!!!!!
So with the Grand Tour post done with, we'll now look at three major cycling countries and the major races they hold. Belgium, Italy, and Spain. How did the teams do in those regions and can numbers back up what our impressions tell us about the unique flavor of pro cycling in each region? More importantly can numbers tell us something new, or just shamelessly lie about the whole mess?
In future posts I'll delve deeply into each region; here I'm contrasting the regions. On the flip I'll start with a dreaded table but before I get to that, a word about the regions I'm neglecting.
France- This is the tough region to neglect but I'm taking a cue from what Chris wrote a week or so ago. May French VDS races are more world events than French regional events. The Tour is totally a world event but so is the Dauphine and Paris-Nice. Paris-Roubaix I'm including in Belgium while Paris-Tours is so vanilla to me that it could be anywhere. Still it's a judgement call but I'm going with the idea that to get the full flavor of French pro cycling you have top go to the Coupe races, which fly below the VDS radar mostly.
I realize that this slights the French teams. However its interesting to see what French teams do elsewhere. One other team that leaving France out of this study messes with is Garmin, at least last year. As you'll slowly see Garmin did very very little outside of France last year. That will probably change-somewhat, this year. At least Garmin better hope it will.
Germany/Eastern Europe- So much time, so few races. Hopefully Germany will become a real pro cycling region again.
Okay. One more thing on definition of Regions.
- Belgium means all the VDS cobbles races, including Paris-Roubaix, plus the Ardennes trio, including Amstel, plus the later two stage races, Ster Elektroer, and Eneco/Benelux. There are 20,530 VDS points up for grabs.
-Spain means the three single day races, the four week stage races, and the Vuelta. Racers compete for 17,929 VDS points.
- Italy means the one week-long stage race, the five single day races, and the Giro. 19,406 VDS points for the taking.
Jump!

So. On to the comparative list:
| Category | Belgium | Italy | Spain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total VDS Points | 20530 | 19406 | 17929 |
| # of teams winning points | 30 | 26 | 30 |
| Points won by non PT teams | 2815 | 5387 | 2061 |
| % points won by non PT teams | 13.7% | 27.8% | 11.4% |
| Points won- top 5 all teams | 10005 | 8358 | 9273 |
| % points won top 5 points all teams | 48.7% | 43.1% | 51.7% |
| Points won- top 10 all teams | 15265 | 14303 | 13899 |
| % points won top 10 points all teams | 74.4% | 73.7% | 77.5% |
| Best team, points won | 2450 | 2215 | 3315 |
| Best team, % points won | 11.9% | 11.4% | 18.5% |
Such a little table! No worries: just you wait! BTW, "PT" means Pro Tour teams last year.
So anything interesting so far?
- % points won by non PT teams. Notice how Italy has so many more non-pro tour teams getting results. We'll look more at that in the Italy post but to me it shows how much Italian talent that does not cross its borders. This is aggravated to be sure by ASO's exclusion of LPR last year but even still the national nature of Italian races is more pronounced than the other regions. Or, to put it another way, the regional teams of Belgium and Spain suck more.
- % points won top 5 points all teams. The top five teams in each region:
Belgium: Saxo (2450), Quickstep (2305- hear the gnashing of teeth?), Rabobank (1935 (more gnashing), Columbia (1715), *Lotto (1600- a whole lot of wailing going on!)
Italy: Liquigas (2215), CSF (1815), Saxo (1657), Astana (1815), and Columbia (1306)
Spain: Astana (3315), Caisse d'Epargne (2375), Eustatel! (1230), Saxo (1180), Cofidis! (1173).
This "Italian regional teams are better" meme is again brought out in this category which shows that Italian races are less dominated by the very best (read multinational) pro tour teams.
What's also interesting here is that there are fewer teams winning points in Italian races than the other two regions (26 vs 30 for the other two regions), so you might say that there's a bigger drop-off in quality from the good non PT Italian teams (LPR, CSF, A&S, Barloworld, Tinkoff, big inhale Serramenti PVC Diquigionanni-Androni Giocattoli, and Ceramica Flaminia and the rest then there is in Spain and Belgium.
Notice though in the next category, the top 10 teams, the regions basically even out.
- Notice that the best team in Spain won a lot more points relative, than the other two regions. The #1 teams in each region are Spain-Astana, Belgium-Saxo, Italy-Liquigas. I think that this is because Spain's VDS races are mostly stage races- red meat to Astana, while the other two regions are single day racing orientated which spreads out the winners more. If you take the Giro and Vuelta out of Spain and Italy un-respectively, you get:
| Category | Spain w/o Vuelta | Italy w/o Giro |
|---|---|---|
| Total VDS Points | 8791 | 8758 |
| # of teams winning points | 30 | 23 |
| Points won by non PT teams | 1466 | 3036 |
| % points won by non PT teams | 16.8% | 34.7% |
| Points won- top 5 all teams | 4165 | 4731 |
| % points won top 5 points all teams | 47.4% | 54% |
| Points won- top 10 all teams | 6343 | 7562 |
| % points won top 10 points all teams | 72.2% | 86.3% |
| Best team, points won | 1080 | 1517 |
| Best team, % points won | 12.3% | 17.3% |
So here Italy's uniqueness is even more pronounced: the good non PT teams are seriously competitive here. On the other hand the top teams, pro tour or no, really compete/dominate in the non Grand Tour races.
Other odds and ends:
- Aqua & Sapone. I was surprised at how competitive they are in each region. But that just points out that the Italian non-PT teams travel better than the non PT teams based in Spain, Belgium, or France as you rarely see the later countries' non-PT teams doing squat anywhere outside their home regions. (VDS tip!)
-Cofidis. I was happy to see how well Cofidis did in Spain. 1173 points, 5th best, just behind Saxo. They earned points in five of the eight races so it wasn't just Moncoutie running off and hiding with the KOM Vuelta jersey. Of course this year... no Nuyens, no Chavanel the better, no Monfort, no Scheirlinckx, etc. etc. etc.
- Saxo, which won the most VDS points overall, had the highest average ra nking within the three regions at 2.67. The top top in average ranking:
Saxo- 2.67
Quickstep- 5
3 (tie) Liquigas- 6.33
3. (tie) Columbia- 6.33
5. (tie) Astana 6.67
5. (tie) Lampre 6.67
7. Caisse d'Epargne- 7.33
8. Rabobank- 7.67
9. Gerolsteiner- 10
10. *Lotto- 10.33
Of course average ranking is in many cases here highly misleading because the differences between one and ten in any region is huge.
Back to work. More later.
Comments
How dare you
Let Belgium annex Holland! It should have been the other way around!!!
by Lopex on
Jan 9, 2009 3:53 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
French races
To me, the GP Plouay is a very French race. After that, I don’t know. It’s a hard thing to define: originally they consisted of these completely mad out-and-back marathons like Paris-Brest et Retour, some 1200km. Then they created Paris-Roubaix, only to see it adopted rather forcefully by Belgians. Then the Tour de France, which was French for a while but obviously that’s been invaded by everyone. So maybe Plouay and the Coupe are the heart of French racing?
Wisdom from actual French people would be of use here.
CQRanking.com, you complete me.
by Chris... on
Jan 9, 2009 6:00 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Best line
“the regional teams of Belgium and Spain suck more”
Nice one. Or, more tactfully, Italy has a deeper bench. Nah, I like your way better.
CQRanking.com, you complete me.
by Chris... on
Jan 9, 2009 6:03 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Other explanation
All the big guys how ride in Belgium can do that in one month. They start in Omloop het Volk and end in Parijs-Roubaix. Because the combination is working to buil;d your form to Parijs-Roubaix there are more big guys how are really motivated to ride that month on cobbles. The Italien race are, I think, whole the year. So the big guys are not really focussing on them. But it can be all rubbish because I don’t knoiw which races are included. Secondly. I have to take a look at the Tour of Belgium what the comparison is between PT and non-PT.
But ver nice Ursula.. As usual
Some say the best things in life, are one the inside.
by Frinking on
Jan 10, 2009 1:16 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Ok.. I examined the Tour of Belgium..
I hope you have a quicker way to do that else it must have tak you houers to finish this..
But here are the stats: (Hope it all went ok with the mathematacis)
Total VDS points: 860
winnig teams: 13
Points won by non PT: 332
Percentage: 38,6%
Points won by Belgium: 408
Percentage: 47,44%
Points won by best team (qst): 171
Percentage: 19,8% (Sil 19,2%)
Some say the best things in life, are one the inside.
by Frinking on
Jan 10, 2009 7:42 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Probably something to that.
There are Italian races running all year. Also, Italian racing, because of the terrain, seems to select for more well-rounded riders, and for a greater variety of rider talents. You have a lot of guys like Cunego and Bettini who can climb and sprint, pure sprinters, pure climbers, blah blah. There are races for everyone. There simply aren’t too many Belgian climbers – Monfort and van Huffel are the two I can think of immediately. Quick, how many Italian climbers can you name? Lots.
by gavia on
Jan 11, 2009 7:31 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Excellent info once again
Keep up the great work!
by PopUp Rolen on
Jan 9, 2009 6:35 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Ursula, there really is something kind of freakish about you
(and now I’m off to study these numbers in depth)
Carlos Sastre - Tour de France winner - Born From Jets
by Jens on
Jan 10, 2009 4:47 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
You silly Geat!
Next post will be an updating of the Annals of Fulda.
TAKE IT TO THE HOUSE!
by ursula on
Jan 10, 2009 3:31 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Ha Ha Ha
My thoughts exactly. I like this post but the more I read it the more I feel out of my depth trying to pick a VDS team on scientific grounds. Cyclegirl seems to have aleady claimed the best butts approach so I may go for colours, favourite vowels, or most euphonious surname.
by Monty. on
Jan 11, 2009 1:50 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
LoL and I have my team
Only problem i’m one point over and not sure which Rear I don’t want…
We don't stop playing because we grow old, we grow old because we stop playing.
George Bernard Shaw, 1856-1950
by CycleGirl on
Jan 11, 2009 7:52 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Is there such a thing?
Carlos Sastre - Tour de France winner - Born From Jets
by Jens on
Jan 12, 2009 5:57 AM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
yes, maybe..hehehe
We don't stop playing because we grow old, we grow old because we stop playing.
George Bernard Shaw, 1856-1950
by CycleGirl on
Jan 13, 2009 7:54 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs









