2011 In Review: Women's team & rider of the year
Continuing the season wrapup it's time to nominate your candidates for best female rider and best women's team of 2011. Now, in order to avoid this turning into part 673 in Chris's ongoing Coming Dutch Hegemony series I'm counting on you guys to get a little creative here. The cold hard facts can be found in our VDS Ranking and in the CQ rider & team rankings but as we know the stats don't always tell the whole story (shut up ursula).
So have at . Who deserves the titles of Rider of the Year & Team of the Year? Don't just let us know who, as always on the cafe, the why is every bit as important.
53 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Hmm. Best team is a tricky one because I have to decide between three. Horizon Fitness is an obvious choice, partly because of the huge amount they do to promote women’s cycling with the On The Drops programme. But then there’s HTC-Highroad – I mean, how could you not love a team that counts Judith Arndt, Emma Fahlin, , Amanda Miller, Katie Colclough and Ina-Yoko Teutenberg among its members? However, team of the year for me has to be one that hasn’t even taken part in any races yet: the new Rabobank Women’s Team, the announcement of which may prove to be the best news in women’s cycling for years.
Best rider? That’s tricky too. Giorgia Bronzini is one that springs to mind. Then there’s Emma Pooley and Lizzie Armitstead for their efforts to increase the exposure women’s cycling gets in Britain. Or Lucy Garner for that amazing victory at the Worlds, or Nicole Cooke for the gutsy way she’s clawing her way back to top after most of the cycling press wrote her off, or Clara Hughes for her brilliant breakaway in the Elite Women’s Road Race in Copenhagen. However, just as has been the case for several years now there’s one rider who deserves to be called Female Cyclist of the year more than any of them, and that’s Marianne Vos. Why? Well, I hardly need explain, do I? She’s not just the best female cyclist in the world, she’s very possibly the best cyclist in the world. She wins almost everything she enters, is likable and puts in an admirable amount of work in support of cycling, anti-doping and a range of good causes.
...and she finally showed she kan dominate a GT too
I'm starting to get tired of this long sig
PodiumCafe on Strava
That’s another thing I admire about her. She finds a weakness and goes to work, altering her style and physique until it becomes a strength. What a rider!
VDS-wise, I hate her.
Otherwise, she’s pure awesome from the inside out.
It would be better to get the important stuff out of the way first. Such as: will your riders still wear scarves next year?--Gerard Vroomen
And she could probably give Will a lesson or two in rikshaw driving
Civetta and I would appreciate it.
I'm an admirer too, but
I have to disagree with you there John. Vos trimmed off several kilos (lord knows how!) and surprised herself in the Giro, but she never changed her style.
Marianne has one weakness in ‘style’, but the majority of cycling coaches hold the view that trying to change what comes naturally is a no-no, so I’d predict that Vos is unlikely to ever find a cure for her habit of trying to ‘push’ too hard on the ‘down-stroke’. The irony is, the same weakness is present on the track, on the climbs, in CX and road-racing, as well as in the TTs.
"It wasn’t right from the outset. On a course like that, with the wind against you, you have to keep a big gear turning, but that didn’t work."
That "didn’t work" for obvious reasons: ("pedalling squares" being the main one)
In trying to "keep a big gear turning" Marianne’s ankles ‘collapsed’ (dorsiflexed) when the feet should have been plantar flexed, and vice versa. ‘Big gear’ is an outdated philosophy anyway. Her coaches should know better.
A smooth transfer of power is the essence of biomechanical efficiency. Plus the need to use LESS force and apply it tangentially, over a greater proportion of the circle. i.e. "pedalling-in-circles". Raising your cadence is far better than raising the gear. You get better speed AND better endurance that way, not to mention faster acceleration out of the corners – a real time-saver on a technical course in the wet.
It takes a great deal of trial and error to attain an ‘aero’ position that is also an efficient biomechanical position. (I wonder if Andy Schleck will ever get it right?)
The same laws of physics hold true in the sprint. What’s the betting Bronzini was one gear lower than Vos in Copenhagen? Over-gearing is the cardinal sin of cycling.
Jens on Aug 27, 2011 12:47 PM EDT "Following up on an amazing display of teamwork and brute force by her teammate Marianne Vos……." Even I wouldn’t call that phenomenal solo ride to catch the break "brute force"! My Dutch sister-in-law tells me the expression has the same negative connotations in English and Dutch. "Raw power" would be far more complimentary, Jens.
Souplesse - poetry in motion. Wo/Man & machine in perfect harmony. Bella in sella, and out.
A gentle poke for Jens
Do we have a combined VDS/WVDS champion yet. I don’t want to harass you, because as you know I realise that math is difficult, but I certainly can’t do it myself! And I harbour these wild hopes that I might figure somewhere in the top 20….
I was told there'd be no math.
by platypus on Oct 20, 2011 12:09 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
We do
I’m waiting until the prize announcement to reveal the winner. It’s a long off-season, we have to milk these things for what we can.
But .... but...
We’re impatient and want it all NOW (if not yesterday). #sulk #pout
"...my reverse cyclelogy has paid off." -ant1
I was counting on The Figurehead to do it but since he seems to be asleep at the job......
Annemiek van Vleuten surely is a serious contender for rider of the year. She may very well have had help from being on the same team as Vos but taking 3 World Cups and the overall is no mean feat.
Yes, Annemiek van Vleuten's a contender
I just really like Vos at the moment because she took the time to thank me for an article I wrote about her. Of course, van Vleuten might do the same if I wrote another one about her… :-)
by John Cyclopunk on Oct 20, 2011 1:26 PM EDT up reply actions
Agreed
I really like how van Vleuten rode the World Cup. For me, she’s an obvy pick for rider of the year. Vos for the Giro Donne is also an obvy pick, since she took a step beyond what we knew of her talent. And the duel was Emma Pooley made for exciting racing.
On the team side, the Bloeits get a vote, for showing up and killing it on the major races. I think that was a weakness of the HTC-Highroad women, they won a lot of races around the calendar and deserve a nomination for best team, but they weren’t as much as factor in the world cups.
~ Gavia ~
I'd really like to come up with some clever options to NB
but I just can’t. The way they double/triple outplayed their opponents in the big races plus how they regularly managed to set Vos up well for the stagerace sprints is just too impressive.
Hitec taking a big step up, particularly in the second half of the season where more and more of their riders featured in races, was impressive but you can’t get around the fact that Emma J scored almost all their points in the end.
HTC with lots of riders contributing is fantastic but as you say, the results didn’t quite come in the big races as they have before (the elusive Vårgårda TTT win being the outstanding exception).
Hitec
I really liked watching them develop this year. I feel like theire team started out as all about Emma J, but as the season went on, some of the other riders have grabbed results and started to shine. Very cool to see. To me, this seemed like a bit of an off-year for Emma, but you know, only by her high standards.
~ Gavia ~
In points terms (CQ and unofficially our VDS points) she had a much better year :-)
That’s only half the truth though since she didn’t have a big one day result. Missing out at both RvV and Worlds , her big targets, probably stings. Just like Vos though she had a big stagerace result, winning Thüringen which was massive. Reportedly that win came after a very strong team effort with Hitec doing a lot to control that race for her. That must be a big sign that her teammates are adapting to the higher level and may become an even bigger factor in 2012?
Sure, Thüringen is awesome
and it’s killer that the team was able to step up in the way that she hoped at the beginning of the season. But Emma is a big race rider, you know? So to me, points aside, her usual level means getting a big race win sometime during the season. And I didn’t really see that happen this year. I also didn’t see as many top finishes in the big races as she usually has. LOL, most riders would loovvee to have her results, but relative to what we usually see from her, this year didn’t seem quite as awesome as usual.
~ Gavia ~
I liked that a lot too
and especially that they sent out some of their younger/less experienced riders to race in the smaller races, at the same time as their Emma-focussed team was hitting up the big races
Aka Pigeons!
by Sarah Connolly on Oct 20, 2011 6:59 PM EDT up reply actions
Thank you
I’m busy writing a “Annemiek is the best rider every season”-song. It’s a power ballad.
Badger, badger, badger, badger, badger, badger...
by TheFigurehead on Oct 20, 2011 3:39 PM EDT up reply actions
At least the video will be better than his
Mine will have explosions and firework.
Badger, badger, badger, badger, badger, badger...
by TheFigurehead on Oct 21, 2011 3:09 AM EDT up reply actions
and slo-mo doves, Fonzie clones, zombie choir boys
Don’t think a video like that has been done before.
Badger, badger, badger, badger, badger, badger...
by TheFigurehead on Oct 21, 2011 6:14 AM EDT up reply actions
HTC gets my vote again
Ned Bloeit a real close 2nd
Vos gets my sentimental and objective vote. (But Evie gets my love)
"It's a lovely thing, feeling that momentum. If you're lucky, it's also about grace." Tim Winton
yay evie :)
Nothing not to like there!
On the US side, a shout-out to Colavita. Those girls just lit it up. Lots of attacking and a very aggressive style. I feel like they have flown a bit under the radar here in the U.S. despite their NRC team win.
~ Gavia ~
+1
if you take away the “star rider” on each team (Vos, Emma J, Arndt etc) and recalculate the rankings then HTC would be clear by a country mile = best all round team for me due to strength in depth.
Vos is a more obvious winner than Gilbert. For me the most notable moment of her year was her patent disappointment with her worlds TT ride. A winter concentrating a little more on that and a double Olympic gold medalist may be on the horizon for next year. She is, and remains, all kinds of awesome.
Almost like the men's team
the depth of this team is amazing. Wins come from everywhere. This HTC mens/women’s cycling thing was unigue and will be greatly missed.
"It's a lovely thing, feeling that momentum. If you're lucky, it's also about grace." Tim Winton
Emma Johannssen
for looking so good on a bike! (And rescuing my VDS team)
I was told there'd be no math.
How can you pick anyone other than Vos?
OK Judith Arndt bounced back after a couple of years where injuries just seemed to hunt her down, Emma Pooley had a surprisingly good year despite breaking her collar bone and missing loads and loads of races that really suited her, and Emma Johansson had yet another of those great season where she would be the dominant rider if Marianne Vos wasn’t around. An Ullrich of our age. WIthout the doughnuts and the drugs.
Are we going to do an up and coming rider because that one is far more fun? I liked Eliza Longo B for all her suicidal, Johnny Hoogerland tpye, attacks at the beginning of the year. Or Emilie Moberg for being so smiley in the team photo at the start of the year that we could all wisely say “yes we’ve heard of her before” when she started winning races in August. Or Pauline F-P for the first half of her season (even if it looks like the French MTB people have stolen her until the Olympics).
Best team? HTC have been great as ever, but hats off to Garmin Cervelo for general openness in discussions all year, and I like the way that the signing of Emma J seems to have given a boost to everyone at Hitec. And one more thumbs up to Horizon for coming here and giving us lots of behind the scenes reports.
One more vote...
For Vos as Best rider.Giro Donne results on top of everything else clinches the deal for me and put her ahead of Vleuten for sure. Plus, I’s a mark on her carrer and it can’t go unnoticed.
Best team… HTC. When you consider the triangule results+depth+teamwork , they get a slight edge on other teams. (and I really value depth).
A more heated discussion could be. Who would you choose for best rider of the year (men and women?)
If I had to pick a British rider
I’d probably choose Pooley for her brilliant suggestions on improving women’s cycling and the exposure it receives (or doesn’t, at present). Lizzie Armitstead would be second, then Lucy Garner for that superb Worlds ride.
by John Cyclopunk on Oct 21, 2011 3:17 AM EDT up reply actions
Pooley always gives such great value for money with her interviews
and this year she excelled herself, such a quotable rider!
Aka Pigeons!
by Sarah Connolly on Oct 21, 2011 3:37 AM EDT up reply actions
I'm surprised she got so many VDS points
what with Aude being cut, and missing out on Luxembourg and the Fleche Wallonne.
Me too
Next year I’m going much more sprinty
Aka Pigeons!
by Sarah Connolly on Oct 21, 2011 1:01 PM EDT up reply actions
Now, my vote for team is the Italian National Team
just for the way they destroyed everyone else at the Worlds… for the third year in a row! I loved it – Cantele harassing the train formation, Elisa Longo B being so active, Baccaille, who’s such a great sprinter in her own right, leading out Giorgia Bronzini. And Bronzini herself, of course – I love love love love that Óscar Freire style sprinting!
(have to admit, I really wanted Vos to win the Worlds, because I am a super fan. She’s such a nice person, on twitter, friendly at races, really sweet and genuine. And a huge champion. I never would have predicted her winning the Giro)
Other top moments of the year for me include Pooley at the Trofeo Binda – I loved her 100 attacks, and the way she escaped on the flat, and had ground everyone down so much that everyone missed the decisive moment!
Getting to see an hour of each day of the Giro Donne was fantastic – and taught me SO much and made me so happy.
I need to think some more about this, but my personal highs were the races I went to, the riders and teams who were so friendly & generous with their time & talked to me & gave prizes for vds, and all the people I met through women’s cycling! Obviously I am a fan of Horizon, because they are so awesome and took me to races, but my other huge thanks is to Jens, for being the Best Host Ever! Really, you should book in at Chez Jens for all your Scandivanian holiday needs!
Aka Pigeons!
ps, i love this article and the chance to think about this!
Thanks so much, Jen!
Aka Pigeons!
by Sarah Connolly on Oct 20, 2011 7:09 PM EDT up reply actions
Gah, Jens, not Jen!
Thanks Jen for everything YOU do, thanks Jens for this!
Aka Pigeons!
by Sarah Connolly on Oct 20, 2011 7:33 PM EDT up reply actions
Thanks man
I don’t feel so bad about my Zanger Rinus post anymore now. Well at least Bluffy wasn’t 1,5

by 
















