Podium Cafe: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Steve McNair Found Shot to Death


This Tour in History

We've had plenty of occasions lately to say that what we've just witnessed in this Tour de France, and now that it's a few km from over, let me take a crack at it.

Star-divide

Best Tour Ever?

I voted in our poll for this year as the greatest Tour of the modern era, but a fairer estimate would be that it falls short of the 1989 Tour. That race featured two established champions going toe-to-toe, whaling away at each other, trading leads before LeMond's epic and improbable final say. By comparison, this Tour was pretty strange, and the GC comp seemed stuck in neutral all the way to the Alps, before it started its dash into history.

So What Was It?

  • Landis' win on stage 17 was the most impressive, exhilirating ride I have ever witnessed. Never have so many people been moved to type "are you fucking kidding me?" about a bike race.
  • You could argue that the conclusion was the most dramatic in Tour history (versus 1989) -- tough call, but arguable.
  • Or, how about the most deserved Tour win ever, or at least recent times?
  • Easily the most wide-open Tour since the mid-90s; and the closest Tour since 1989.
  • Possibly my favorite Tour ever, or at least in 17 years. But there's no metric for this...

So What of Landis?

Landis is a transitional figure. Obviously his win will go down as one of the great unforgettable moments in the race's history, and I'm talking way high up on the list. But in all likelihood he's a bridge to the next era, not the subject of it. He'll make medical history if he so much as finishes another Tour, and my guess is that it will take him more than a year to even approach his former level. The muscle trauma of surgery just seems too over the top.

And then what?

Completely wide open. We've obviously seen a new generation of emerging talent coming on the past couple years, and over time some of them will come to the fore as Tour protagonists or winners. But we've also seen the value of experience here, and people need to be patient with talents like Cunego and Valverde (to name a couple). Meanwhile, the guys who made this year's race great -- Pereiro, Sastre, Kloden, etc. -- will be around a while, and there's no evidence that Ivan Basso won't come back to claim his place in the Tour too, with his name cleared. We shall see about that.

0 recs | Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

This Tour in History
Great analysis of '89 and '06.  I agree that "the two established champions going toe-to-toe..." was the difference. '06 provided great excitement and should be considered 2nd or 3rd best ever, but '89 was the best.

by CCB VW on Jul 23, 2006 12:44 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

I think the course
provide to be the perfect setting for drama.  As opposed to the Giro which IMHO should be re-named the Italian Nat'l Climbers Championship. I must admit, I missed the TTT, but looking back, I wouldn't change a thing.

by Mr Van P on Jul 23, 2006 4:28 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Landis was great, but the team tactics stunk.
Floyd's ride in the Alps was epic, both his bonk and his Phoenix flight from those ashes.  There were several other days of great racing, Honchar in both TT, Rassmussen's monster mountain day, great sprints and breakaways.  And the yellow jersey changing hands so often, it may have been one of the most entertaining ever.
   There were times when teams should have chased but didn't.  It was this lack of action that shaped the outcome.  Pereiro was given a podium position because teams didn't defend their GC guys.  True they were short handed by
the drug busts but then they could have formed an alliance.
  Maybe the best thing was that they got the drug busts out of the way before the race and the race itsself was run without midnight raids of team hotels and suspicion.  It was just the riders putting on a great show.  That part was absolutely great.

by flying dog on Jul 23, 2006 6:46 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

I voted for 1989
You're right, the back and forth between LeMond and Fignon was epic and puts that one slightly in front of 2006.

But Floyd's stage 17 win is the most dramatic TdF stage I can remember, beating out LeMond's 1989 ITT win IMO.

OTOH, Fignon in 1989 beats out T-Mobile this year for the Homer Simpson Doh! Award.  He lostng the whole freaking Tour just because he didn't want to wear a helmet in the last time trial. Wear a damn helmet for less than an hour, Laurent, and you win the Tour!

by socal on Jul 23, 2006 9:52 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Every sprint, every cobble, every mountain pass from the world of Pro Cycling
Start posting on Podium Cafe »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Tuco_1_small
ROAD RACE: Nat'l Champ. Repository
Unicorn_160_x_160_facing_other_way_small
VDS: National Championship Bonus Points

Recent FanPosts

Jim_small
The Pursuit of Green
Small
The Tour de France Stage 2
J0397446_small
Versus live streaming?
Small
Giro Donne – Stage 3
Small
Tour de France Stage 1
Small
Giro Donne – Stage 2 Time Trial
Small
Giro Donne – Stage 1
Small
MY OPINION ON THE TOUR DE FRANCE
Bowling_small
I have a strong feeling how Versus coverage is going to go
Small
Giro Donne – Opening Prologue

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

Our Sponsors!

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recent FanShots

Greipel gets win 11
Jamie Barrow wins Maratona dles Dolomites
"Cancellara will be top five"
A Tour de France Primer (for Americans)
Best Tweet Ever: And It is By Brad Wiggins!
Kim Kirchen (Team Columbia-HTC) Recovers from Broken Collarbone in Time to Ride the Tour de France.
Theo Bos suspended 1 month
Joe Parkin, "6 Years in a Rain Cape"
Pearl Izumi parody of cycling controversies, this one focusing on the what-ifs of performance enhancing clothing.
This video is an attempt to show the ambience at the final hour of the Nice Ironman competition. A lame attempt i'll admit, but wth? If you're ever going to finish towards the end of an ironman, i suggest Nice as the place to do it. The applause and support and general ambience at the end is really remarkable. Dj's, pom-pom girls, people dancing, shouting, dance music blasting ... Some finishers just go on through, others raise their arms or just have a huge smile, one guy did some pushups while the dj counted for him, another did a cartwheel, some ran through with their little kids holding their hands. And this all 8 hours after the winners have finished. 

When i went out my door to walk over to see the last hour or so of the Ironman, the first thing i saw was a guy across the street, pushing his triathlon bike, head hanging down to his chest, walking with a pronounced. Painful. Slow. Trudge. Medal around his neck. He'd done well. Hope he felt better the next day.

Then i got to the promenade and started seeing more of the people who'd finished: one guy asleep on the pavement with his wife by his side in all the raucous noise and confusion and crowds everywhere. Then the medical tent - massages, those heat blanket thingies, oxygen, people limping aorund, Oy! 

Then every now and then you see a finisher with a medal around their neck who look fresh as a daisy, like they've just had a nice walk in the park.

Then finally you get to the finish line ... and that's the video. At the end there's a fireworks display (no one timed their finish to coincide with it this year) and then apparently a few hundred people stayed all night to party on the prom next to the beach until daybreak.

I could not do an ironman even if i wanted to, but i'll be there again next year to help welcome the last finishers in.

Post_icon New FanShot All FanShots Carrot-mini