Podium Cafe: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: GoldenBlogs Interview With Gary Tyrrell Bar-right-arrows



Millar: The Buck Stops With The Teams

David Millar, who knows a thing or two about doping, has told VeloNews something I find very interesting: that if you want to stop doping, you need the teams to step in. His plan would follow the T-Mobile model of not only controlling the riders' lives more but screening them before they sign on. Teams have a good idea of what riders are up to, and can wield the power of the checkbook to force change.

This might be the most useful idea in existence right now. Let's face it: the judicial process is a mess, not only because it's poorly set up, but doping positives are simply hard to pin down as a scientific matter. The cat-and-mouse game of masking makes positives difficult to get even when the rider is cheating. Worse, the positives that are found are being challenged as false, or unexplained, or perhaps subterfuge... and IMHO the challenges raise enough troubling questions to make me and others throw up our hands. Or our lunch.

But turning it back on the teams... this can work. Teams can deal in innuendo. They don't need a positive test; they can just choose not to sign (or re-up) a rider over whom there are serious questions. This has a guilty-til-proven suggestion to it, so the power of the purse should be used as fairly as possible. But at least if the teams show they won't take suspicious riders, it places a great deal of pressure on riders to stay clean and above suspicion.

The ultimate solution to the doping problem is to create an environment where there is more pressure to be clean than there is to dope, and riders will be forced to clean up the sport. Passing the responsibility onto the teams beats waiting around for the judicial process or the UCI to command changes, because it shifts that pressure... maybe not right away, but the message to the next generation is that if you want a job, steer far away from even the taint of drugs. Over time, this just might work.

0 recs | Comment 11 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

My suggestion all along
has been to suspend the teams along with the riders.  I personally don't believe that companies like T-mobile or other sponsors are completely naive to the fact that athletes on their payrolls are doping.  However when an athlete is caught, the team quickly distances themselves from them.   If the team can't indemnify themselves from said athletes, watch how quickly things get cleaned up....

....of course there's always the risk that no company larger than Tinkoff credit systems would ever get into cycling...

Vlaenderen die Leu

by Mr Van P on Mar 29, 2007 9:06 PM EDT   0 recs

YES
Provided the team is'nt the one controling the doping.

by Brandontw9 on Mar 30, 2007 1:07 AM EDT   0 recs

Definitely a problem
It seems like systematic doping was pretty common not too long ago.

Yes 2003 was a simpler time, Britney still had her hair, The US wasn't embroiled in a never ending war... er...

I'm rewatching the 2003 TdF--Kelme was still around, and that was when we had the famous Manzano collapse by the side of the road.

I felt like I lost contact with my own body. I realised they had cut my jersey open in the ambulance and were giving me an injection and electrocardiagram tests.

"When I got back to the hotel the team made me do interviews [to explain things]. But I didn't abandon for the reason that some people have said, it wasn't because of the sun."

I think part of the problem, again, is the lack of cohesive authority in the sport. So you can have teams that are clean, and teams that, perhaps, aren't clean at all. I am sure there are teams that are still using systematic doping, blood doping + hormones to prepare their riders.

-K-

by KevinK on Mar 30, 2007 12:06 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

That's a bit along the same lines
as my idea last year, during Fuentes' case.

Why not intervene (by UCI) and place qualified independent doctors inside the teams as well? They should be on the pay-roll of the teams, which wouldn't cost the UCI anything.
Yet, the pre-training of the doctors should be in tracing of doping as well, apart from the usual medical training.
By the same token: The UCI should have doctors on their pay-roll as well, to doublecheck on the work the teamdoctors do. In that way you at least get inside info on what every team is up to, any suspicious result can be checked even before races start, hence solving possible problems during races as well.

Of course, the team(s) would now be accountable for the behaviour of its riders, not just the riders themselves. That would provide enough leverage in itself, i imagine.

You may never get rid of doping altogether, yet, the image of cycling would be the benefactor with this approach.

by DZI on Mar 30, 2007 9:08 AM EDT   0 recs

Is it just me or
does anyone else read things like this and wonder if we can come up with seemingly very viable solutions to the problem then how come it seems so hard for the powers that be to come up with them.
The Crystal Method

Race Calendar

by Clydesdale on Mar 30, 2007 9:14 AM EDT   0 recs

Been wondering
about that for years now.

I'm not a doctor, nor a manager of some sort. Just someone who loves this sport, without being an active cyclist because of a bad knee.

Yet, common sense should dictate solutions. All those organisations, riders and teams are so deep into cycling that there's no helicopter view present, i imagine.

by DZI on Mar 30, 2007 9:42 AM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Emphasis on "seemingly"
As good as our suggestions sound I really don't think any of us fans have enough knowledge to come up with any workable solutions.  On the other hand, the folks that have the power and knowledge only seem interested in grand-standing.  Those with the knowledge but no power (the riders) are routinely ignored or persecuted for speaking out.  I'm encouraged that Millar so far is being tolerated to say the things he's saying.  

Couple more Millar points worth mentioning: (a) the riders don't like the pressure to dope, and (b) a lot of the pressure comes from the team management, the "win at all costs" mentality.  

Just like any other vice embedded in a culture, the ultimate solution to doping has to come from within the culture, not from without.  Ramping up the punishment ala WADA will have little effect.

by ghisallo on Mar 30, 2007 10:04 AM EDT to parent up   0 recs

i just wish Millar
would go public with more specific info. How did he do it?, where did he get it? , who advised/instructed him? and so on. It's all good and well that he is taking a public stand against doping but he is in a unique position to cast a light on some of the practices outsiders can only speculate on and it is a pity he isn't forced to share his insights.With better knowledge comes better ways to fight the problem.

by Jens on Mar 30, 2007 1:22 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

The newspapers would love that
but how would it help rehabilitate the sport exactly?  

by ghisallo on Mar 30, 2007 2:44 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

The Landis case is a good example
After news broke about him using testosterone,sources started saying "thats ridiculous no one would ever use testosterone in that way, it just wouldn't work". If we had records from caught cheaters like Millar, detailing how they used products and beat the system, anti-doping agencies would be in a better position to make an informed judgedment on the merits of defenses like that. They could also adapt measures to become more effective if they knew what to look for and when.

by Jens on Mar 30, 2007 4:08 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Current managers and directors and etc.
have a cultural prejudice and financial stake in keeping things exactly the way they are:

the sport has always been based on exploiting the riders--which is why you have a system set up so that Lefevere or whoever can pull an Inspector Renault if one of their riders turns up positive "Le Dopage . . . in my team, why I had no idea!!  Round up the usual suspects!!"

Making the holding companies who own the teams--and NOT directly the sponsors--responsible for doping infractions and for maintaining transparent records of riders' health records would go a long way towards cleaning up the sport.  Something of this has already happened with Saiz--

by R Mc on Mar 30, 2007 10:01 AM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

The Pro Tour, the Grand Tours, and every rider from A to Zubeldia

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Imgp2649_small
Just call me stumpy
Hincapie_silhouette_small_small
Do We Think This is the Real Alberto Contador on Twitter?
Org_mlt_small
Gieten superprestige report
Photo_small
Lance just announced on twitter...
Smalljersey_small
Cyclocross Corner
Indiana_flag_small
Having our cake
Small
Trivia Monday November Results...
_dsc0007red_small
Riis Loses Sponsor to Bankruptcy
2008_tirreno_adriatico_stage3_climb_small
Napolitano Russian Bound
Dv2005-08_small
Quick Note From Mannheim (Formerly Luxor)...

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recent FanShots

This is the entrance to the old velodrome I happened by in Buenos Aires.  Tried to get in, but the guard ran after me and started yelling about calling the police.  The "Lo siento, no entiendo.  Soy turisto." thing didn't work.  At all.  Ah well.

Did a bit of searching and found this January 07 story about the velodrome here.  Built for the 1951 Pan-American Games, that track yielded 152 medals for Argentian cyclists.  Perón glory years, indeed.  Turns out that it's been closed for 10 or so years, mostly used as a tow lot.  There was a restoration plan in place, but it's fallen beyond repair and is slated for demolition.  A shame.
LBS: Cairo, Egypt near Ramses Station.  I've put more, non-cycling related Egypt pics up in my original thread.
Sporza Quiz
NYT article on high-tech bike fitting
Those of you with kids, get your welding gear
NYT reports new bike lanes for Manhattan
Mike Barry writes about 'Cross (NY Times)
For all the Lebowski fans here, in memory of Yma Sumac
"Madison is like a video game on a bike" - interview with Svein Tuft
Tim Duggan, Danny Pate, and some loser

Post_icon New FanShot All FanShots Carrot-mini


Site Meter